• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Marin Wealth Advisors

Marin Wealth Advisors, LLC.

Registered investment Advisor

  • Investment Advice
    • Help with Your Investments
    • Investment Standards
    • ESG Investing
    • ESG Portfolio Management
  • Financial Planning
    • Stock Compensation Advisors
    • 529 College Savings Plan
    • Estate Planning Advisors
    • Personal Financial Coach
  • Retirement Planning
    • Retirement Financial Advisor
    • Early Retirement
    • Employer 401K Plans
    • IRA Rollover Accounts
    • Business Retirement Plans
  • Online Wealth Advisor
  • About
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact
  • Client Portal
  • Investment Advice
    • Help with Your Investments
    • Investment Standards
    • ESG Investing
    • ESG Portfolio Management
  • Financial Planning
    • Stock Compensation Advisors
    • 529 College Savings Plan
    • Estate Planning Advisors
    • Personal Financial Coach
  • Retirement Planning
    • Retirement Financial Advisor
    • Early Retirement
    • Employer 401K Plans
    • IRA Rollover Accounts
    • Business Retirement Plans
  • Online Wealth Advisor
  • About
  • Blog
  • Locations
  • Contact
  • Client Portal

Is Index Investing Good For Our Society And Economy In The Long-Run?

June 23, 2015

Is Index Investing Good For Our Society And Economy In The Long-Run?

I work for a firm that recommends index investing for a portion and often a majority of client portfolios. It’s hard to form an argument against it. Broad diversification and low fees with the majority of active managers underperforming their index fund counterparts in recent years. I’ve always accepted the general consensus that using index funds make sense. I still do… for now.

My question: Is a society made up entirely of index investors a good thing?

The United States has had the strongest economy in the world for decades. Most economists would cite easy access to capital for our businesses as a major contributor to our nation’s economic success. On the flip side, lack of capital is the #1 cause for business failure. So I think it’s safe to conclude that the easier it is for businesses to raise funds via stock and bond offerings, the greater the chance of their success.

U.S. public companies are required to release reliable financial information about their operations on a quarterly basis with external audits done annually. This information is what allows investors to make informed decisions as to where to put their money. The high standards for reliability build confidence in our system as a whole and for this reason, money from around the world pours into our borders to invest in our companies’ stocks and bonds. This gives us a clear economic advantage.

As a result of frequent and transparent communication of financial results, companies with the strongest balance sheets, revenue growth, expanding margins, etc. garner the most investor capital. Companies with dismal balance sheets, dwindling revenue, and low liquidity don’t raise as much cash.

In the early years of the stock market, mom & pop investors had difficulty affording quality research with which to make informed investments in individual companies. Then came the mutual fund. All of a sudden, regular people could pool their money together to make it cost-effective to hire research teams (i.e. portfolio managers and analysts) originally reserved for the ultra-rich. The middle class now had an economically viable method for identifying attractively valued companies.  These research teams would comb through the financial reports of hundreds of companies to build a “fund”  they felt contained quality businesses worthy of their investors’ capital. In my opinion, this was a MAJOR step in the right direction for our economy. The middle class could finally participate in the growth of our nation’s best companies.

In today’s market, we now have index funds which compete against actively managed mutual funds for client dollars. An index fund is a group of securities batched together with no direct weight placed on the quality of the companies in the group (and hence no research). Rather, the weight assigned to each company in the fund is based off of differences in market capitalization of each company. These differences in market capitalization among the companies in the index group can only exist if some investors in the marketplace ARE investing actively, not passively. The active selection of an investor choosing one company over a competitor creates value differences (i.e. market-cap differences) that drive the company weightings within our index funds. Coke or Pepsi? Mercedes or BMW? Williams-Sonoma or Restoration Hardware?  The larger the market cap of a company, the heavier the weight in the index fund.

What does this tell us? An index investor is piggy-backing off of the value decisions made by the active investors in the market without paying for the research. Sounds great right? But what if our active investors who do all the work in terms of research give-in and jump on the index band wagon? What happens to our value differences among companies in any given index? What happens to our economic advantage?

 

Category iconUncategorized

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Everyone Expects 25bp, but What’s Next (January 27 Market Recap)
  • Bad News is Now Just Bad News; Inflation at Fed’s 2% Target (January 20 Market Recap).
  • CPI Good, Inflation Expectations Decreasing, Will the Fed Care (January 13 Market Recap) ? 
  • No Santa Rally but Average Hourly Earnings Save the Day (January 6 Market Recap)
  • Fed Continues to Crash the Party – December 16 Market Recap

Categories

  • Asset Allocation (1)
  • Education (94)
  • ESG Investing (1)
  • Estate Planning (4)
  • Financial Planning (10)
  • Investment Management (43)
  • Investments (16)
  • Retirement Planning (12)
  • Stock Compensation (2)
  • Uncategorized (19)

Working With Marin Wealth Advisors

Fee-only Investment Management
Financial Planning at an hourly rate
No commission, no conflict of interest

Request a complimentary one-hour financial review


    Footer

    Marin Wealth Advisors LLC

    899 Northgate Drive, Suite 300
    San Rafael, CA 94903
    415-458-5880

    50 California St. Suite 1500
    San Francisco, CA 94111
    415-472-5885

    1901 Harrison Street, Suite 1100
    Oakland, CA 94612
    510-217-8100

    2121 California Blvd, Suite 290
    Walnut Creek CA 94596
    925-374-4899

    info@marinwealthadvisors.com

    All Content Copyright © 2023 Marin Wealth Advisors, Registered Investment Advisor, Marin County, CA

    Disclaimer:
    The MWA website and blogs are limited to the dissemination of general information pertaining to its advisory services, together with access to additional investment-related information, publications, and links.
    All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly.

    No information contained on this website or blog constitutes tax, legal, insurance or investment advice.

    Best Financial Advisors in San Francisco
    Financial Advisors in Marin County

    Stay Connected: